KINGSTON — Commercial fishermen have very different perceptions of the impact of the Block Island Wind Farm than do recreational fishermen, according to a survey of both groups by a University of Rhode Island doctoral student.
Of the 25 fishermen interviewed, all of whom said they regularly fish in the area of the wind farm, the recreational fishermen generally perceive the turbines positively while the commercial fishermen see them as mostly negative.
The results of the study, funded by Rhode Island Sea Grant, were reported at a meeting last month of the American Geophysical Union in Washington, D.C.
“Little is known about the impacts of offshore wind farms on marine users in the United States, and it’s critical to understand these impacts in context,” said Tayla ten Brink, the URI student who conducted the survey with Professor Tracey Dalton. “Generally, our findings show there are uneven impacts on the different fishing sectors.”
According to ten Brink, almost all of the fishermen agreed that there is more recreational fishing taking place in the vicinity of the wind turbines than before the turbines were installed. That’s because the turbine support structures serve as artificial reefs that attract a wide variety of fish and marine invertebrates. Cod and other species not found in the area before are now being observed, for instance.
As a result, charter boats and recreational fishermen are drawn to the area that they seldom visited before the wind farm installation. The wind farm has also become a prime destination for recreational spearfishing.
The commercial fishermen surveyed said that the increase in recreational fishermen — as well as what they called “wind farm tourists” — were an inconvenience because they increased activity on their fishing ground.
The commercial fishermen also expressed fears that their gill nets and other gear would become entangled in the recreational fishermen’s gear, forcing them to be more cautious about where they fish. They said they also worried about running into the turbines with their vessels. The end result, they said, is fewer places for them to conduct their business.
The survey results could have implications for future planning for wind farm development.
“Climate change is a huge problem worldwide, and renewable energy resources could reduce CO2 emissions by half, so if we’re planning on using offshore wind, it’s important to understand the concerns and the pros and cons of the structures being out there,” said ten Brink. “Once we understand, it will be much easier to have a productive discussion about how to go forward with offshore wind development.
“As with any large-scale project, offshore wind development can be done right or wrong,” she added. “These results inform how it can be done right, with minimal negative impact and maximum positive impact.”
Ten Brink suggested that the survey results might inspire wind farm developers to build relationships with charter boats and recreational fishing organizations that would benefit from their installations. Developers might also ease the concerns expressed by commercial fishermen about running into the structures by supporting the acquisition of new navigation equipment for the fishermen.
“The survey results open up a lot of ways to create win-win situations,” she said.
Ten Brink cautioned, however, that her results only reflect the impact of one small wind farm in operation for only one year. Once the novelty wears off for the recreational fishermen and the commercial fishermen learn to live with the turbines, their perceptions may change, she said.
“There were fishermen who were really worried about the impacts and were pleased when the impacts weren’t too bad, but they’re still worried about the impacts of more and more turbines in the future,” ten Brink concluded.
Vineyard Wind offers $6.2 million for fishermen
PROVIDENCE (AP) — An offshore wind farm project is offering to pay $6.2 million to compensate Rhode Island commercial fishermen who will lose access to grounds where they catch squid, Jonah crab and lobsters.
Vineyard Wind is also offering to create a $23 million fund to research new fishing gear and technology to support safe fishing around wind turbines.
The state Department of Environmental Management has projected that the commercial fishing industry could see a loss of at least $30 million in revenue over the 30-year lifespan of the wind farm off the coast of Martha's Vineyard in Massachusetts, The Providence Journal reported.
Vineyard Wind, which plans to install 84 turbines, said it disagreed with the state's analysis and called its mitigation package "comprehensive." The company submitted its proposal to the state Fishermen's Advisory Board and the Coastal Resources Management Council on Wednesday. The project requires the approval of the CRMC.
Vineyard Wind and the advisory board agreed to meet in closed session to discuss the offer.
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., criticized the company's approach, which failed to meet the fishermen's request that it realign and widen the spacing of its turbines. The senator, in a tweet, suggested that Vineyard wind was following in the footsteps of the failed Cape Wind project in Massachusetts. "Vineyard Wind ignores the lesson, tries to roll fishermen. Not smart, and bad start for an industry that must share the ocean with other users."