ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Community Calendar

Community Artists Program
10 a.m. - 4 p.m. Charlestown

Families in Nature
11 a.m. - 1 p.m. Charlestown

Time, Tide & Water exhibit
1 p.m. - 5 p.m. Westerly

"Shakespeare in Hollywood"
2 p.m. - 3:30 p.m. Westerly

Opening Reception
2 p.m. - 4 p.m. Westerly

Movies in the Park
7:30 p.m. - 9 p.m. Westerly

RI Blood Drive
9 a.m. - Noon Charlestown

... View all of today's events


Stay Connected
Friends to Follow


ADVERTISEMENT


Developer appealing housing denial


STONINGTON — Toll Brothers, a developer of high-end homes, is appealing the Planning and Zoning Commission’s recent decision to reject its plan to fix ongoing drainage problems. The eight-page appeal was filed on Jan. 22 in New London Superior Court.

Tom Collier, the lawyer who represented Toll Brothers before the Planning and Zoning Commission, told the Conservation Commission Monday night that Toll Brothers is pursuing another option for the drainage problem, but filed the appeal to keep its options open.

“Toll doesn’t want to be in the business of suing municipalities,” Collier said.

The appeal, filed by attorneys Joseph P. Williams and Beth Bryan Critton of the Hartford firm Shipman & Goodwin, claims that the Planning and Zoning Commission’s denial earlier this month was “unreasonable, arbitrary, illegal, and an abuse of its discretion.”

The luxury home builder purchased the property, located between Whitehall Avenue, Jerry Browne Road, and Pequot Trail, from Clairemonte Estates in 2010. The subdivision plan for the 48-lot Clairemont development had been approved six years earlier. Neighbors had challenged that decision, but their appeal was dismissed in Superior Court in 2006. After Toll Brothers bought the property, the company changed the plans to a 46-lot development to be called Old Mystic Estates at Stonington.

However, town engineer Larry Sullivan noticed a problem in the drainage plan that had previously been approved.

The error included an inlet pipe on Whitehall Pond that was thought to be an outlet pipe. And neighbors downhill from the southwest side of the subdivision suffered from mudslides that ran from the empty lots.

Toll Brothers contracted with an engineering firm, Cheshire-based Milone & MacBroom, to create a new drainage plan for the property. The plan involved the use of three retention basins, changed some lot lines, and took up one building lot.

The plan received the approval of the Inland Wetlands and Watercourse Commission in June, and Toll Brothers presented it to the Planning and Zoning Commission shortly afterward. Because of concerns expressed by neighbors, the commission decided to hold a public hearing on the application. Sullivan, the town engineer, supported the plan at that time.

According to the company’s appeal, an engineer retained by opponents of the plan, Geoffrey L. Jacobson, raised questions about the plan and provided information to the Planning and Zoning Commission after the public hearing. Toll Brothers asserts that a letter submitted by Jacobson was based on “assumptions that lack a substantial basis in fact,” and that it was denied the opportunity to respond to the letter.

Without an approved drainage plan, Toll Brothers said it cannot build on any of the sites in the pond’s watershed. The commission’s denial “effectively prohibits the development of twenty-three (23) lots that were approved by the commission in its 2004 subdivision approval.”

The appeal asks the court to reverse the decision and have the town pay unspecified costs. Stonington has until Feb. 25 to respond.

lrovetti@thewesterlysun.com



Back to Stonington
Top Stories of the Week

Hope Valley-Wyoming fire chief nears his last call after 51 …
HOPE VALLEY — Sylvia Stanley is preparing for the day in mid-July when her husband, Fred, who has served as Hope Valley-Wyoming fire chief for … more ...

Police logs: Thursday, July 2, 2015 …
Richmond Kari L. Scholle, 26, of 370 Hillsdale Road, Richmond, was charged on June 24 with operating a motor vehicle with a suspended license. She … more ...

8 vying for Westerly council vacancy …
WESTERLY — Two former councilors, a licensed clinical social worker, and the town’s former human resources director are among a field of eight candidates seeking … more ...

Belting it out at Fenway: Grillo to sing national anthem …
PAWCATUCK — It came as no surprise to Michael Grillo’s friends and family when they heard he’d hit it out of the park during his … more ...

Fourth of July parades, fireworks, and celebrations …
Parades STONINGTON Stonington’s Fourth of July all town parade kicks off Saturday, July 4, at 10 a.m. at Wadawanuck Square, winds through the streets of … more ...

Comments